Speculation Third Item For Yahya

I was thinking that the three items needed all corresponds to the items that yahya wants in the quest


Talking mushroom = brown mushroom

??? = red mushroom


Black spoon = bowl







So my speculation is that the third item is/is related to a red mushroom.

 

What makes you think the talking mushroom is brown and not red? It comes in both textures.
Also, which bowl? A misc item bowl is entirely plausible, Yahya's stained bowl is undroppable, and idk about any other bowl in WC.
Also, who said it was 3 items?

EDIT: I came to a realization and retract most of what I said.

 

The strange mushroom has a red mushroom sprite.

What if we try the items in yahya's quest in the exact order he requests them in. Like 3 Strange mushrooms, 1 Talking Mushroom, 1 Black spoon.

 

There is also Illuminated mushroom, used in the quest "The Shadow of The Beast"

 

Illuminated mushrooms are not for the shadow of the beast quest

it's for Realm of the light.

 

We've tried that so many damn times man

 

oh right maybe its the strange mushroom from it