Comments on Profile Post by Aya

If it's not the corrupted dungeon

I'll cry too

same

sowwy xavier your music is great and all but i dislike how you make dungeons pass from "this place sucks i better beat this fast or shit is gonna happen" to "WOOHOO ADVENTURE FREE XP GRIND BATTLE" D:

wait wt lol

compare the galleon graveyard music to the music needlr made
the difference of which makes you feel like you entered here wanting to and because the place isnt spoopy is clear

galleon's graveyard isn't scary though, I think a more dungeony dungeon theme I wrote is the new Underworld Crypt theme

Also, Underworld Crypt DIDN'T HAVE MUSIC before, so, that's why it was added

"galleon's graveyard isnt scary"
UHM thats what i meant...

about the underworld crypt thing
eh, im pretty sure there is a song called "ZombieDungeon" and Underworld Crypt was ZombieDungeon before

at least I remember hearing music during underworld crypt

https://imgur.com/a/lv5Kb
yep

yeah, and its an exact replica of the skeleton dungeon theme, just sped up. It needed its OWN song

well at least it still saves that "eh this place is uncomfortable" ambient...

how is galleon's graveyard not scary it has freaking shark people and undead everywhere and you're at the bottom of a cave in the ocean without anyone knowing you're there and you don't even know if there's a way out at the end.

yeah
and the music feels like watching "He is a pirate" memes

Not all the dungeons are creepy in tone. Thus, why make the music intimidating for those? Yes, there are the ones that are intimidating, but not all of them really are. Galleon's Graveyard, while there is undead everywhere, it is probably pirate themed because, well, the dungeon is more pirate themed. Also, the songs all fit their dungeons, so Idk what the complaint really is about.

I don't hear any of the "WOOHOO ADVENTURE FREE XP GRIND BATTLE" that you complained about @The Shroobs

Which dungeon isn't intimidating? They all are to me.
Also Undergrowth Ruins sounds very funky and happy for the lair of an evil shaman who uses dark magic and lives amongst failed living weapons experiments which are slowly growing in power and consuming stuff at a rapid rate

okay to be fair that one doesn't fit the dungeon very well cause that lore was made after the theme was written

which bit?
it was known slykaar was an evil shaman and the slimes are failed experiments when the dungeon was released, but the dark magic bit only really came in last update.
still, that's fine.

well... actually i just miss the leitmotif all of them had
check all the old ones, you will hear how they all sound pretty similar
i liked how they all sounded like that and now thats gone
your songs are good but they dont fit with what needlr did

make it pirate themed, but at least make me feel like im in a dangerous place not like if i was listening to He is a Pirate and watching memes of that

But how do you make it intimidating, when a pirate themed song sounds basically just like that. Think of the theme as if you're in a whirlpool, or you're in a very stormy night out at sea, you can barely see anything, and lightning is striking here there and everywhere. That's what the stereotypical pirate life is all about, and that song captures that feel. It's not trying to be a meme.

doesn't capture that feel to me

My alert help