Weekly Community Discussion (24/01/2020) - Ingredient Discussion

Not in wynndata if/yet so idk

 

Ok so: I made a spreadsheet detailing if there is an option (per pofession) for every single possible ID. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1IgXPsV7djwuVsE_VZpvBfopG3chyb7sjHEPrUSPe8FM/edit?usp=sharing
Checkmarks:
Green means yes (and good)
yellow im either reviewing for whether they're good/engame viable or I didn't want to give them red but they're not green worthy
red is yes, but not endgame viable, or just only bad option(s)
Highlights:
blue: only possible by flipping
purple: only majors badge option for flipping (alchemism only lul)
Red, unchecked: NO OPTION- PLEASE ADD OPTIONS IMs (this is most of the point of the whole sheet, to point out what's missing)
I did add some notes at the bottom too. Also, feel free to reply with why you think something should be changed or if i missed something. took a couple hours...
Also also feel free to copy and edit your own just dont copy and try to pass it off as urs
its my spam email leave me alone- my name isnt actually bob smith

 

Things like CUR parties could make these very abusable to level up

 

To summarize, what needs to be added (these currently have no options ingame):
For armoring: nothing really, (LQ maybe)
tailoring: exploding, rainbow dmg%
weaponsmithing: rainbow def%, thunder def% positive option (LQ maybe)
woodworking: nothing really, (LQ maybe)
jeweling- overall worst imo. a lot of things need buffs/new, better options, and several things need nerfs. anyway: thorns
scribing: rainbow def%, air def%, (+tier maybe?)
cooking: spell raw, air dmg%, MS, reflection, soul point regen, rainbow dmg% (+tier maaaybe)
alchemism: stealing, intel (wtf), thunder def%, rainbow def%, flipping options (LQ maybe. imo swap crystal organ to alchemism, change dura, maybe buff the lq a little if needed)

________________________________

What desperately needs buffs (not taking into account flipping, as everything should have a positive option imo):
For armoring: better/new regen raw options, intel options and +tier options.
tailoring: poison, +tier
weaponsmithing: surprisingly, nothing really
woodworking: regen raw, rainbow def
jeweling: hoo boy. Melee+spell raw, MR+MS options, reflection, exploding, str, dex
scribing: stealing, LS
cooking: poison
alchemism: LS, flipping options besides major's

 

Alright! It's Friday again so we're going to be locking this thread and moving onto a new topic. You'll still be able to view this thread, its content and its replies by following the link on our main thread here where we'll keep a list updated with every weekly discussion thread. We appreciate all of the responses and discussions this week and hope to see you guys on this week's thread here.

Cheers =)
/locked