Game Mechanics New Class : Jack of all trades

currently weapon is locked to each class so im suggesting a new class that can use all type of weapon and skill this will make player able to make lot more combo for combat but since it will be too op there should be penalty for this class for example : getting less/need more xp to lvl up , less stats/dmg scale

 

ok, but like

no that ruins the balance of the game, and takes away from the specificity of classes, it is way too OP, and you dont have any details. What spells does it have? etc

 

This person proposed the same idea on Discord.

Spoiler: Thread Summary

Reasons why the idea is bad:

• Abilities would be very clunky to manage, and the ATree would be bizarre. Do you have one Atree? Do you have all five? In the latter case, do you have 45 or 225 ability points?
• Builds would be ridiculously unbalanced (for instance, combining Mage spell damage with Cataclysm).

Another thing that happened:

• Someone else suggested races, which is barely linked to the original idea. I opposed this on the grounds that it makes no sense, lorewise. The rest of the thread was mostly me arguing with races guy on whether fantasy races should be added.
• One guy in the thread got concerned that this idea, and the races idea, and a different thread were all anime-based suggestions. Didn't explain why that was the case.

Yeah, this is a terrible idea, sorry.

 

Beyond the fact we don't take class suggestions, this is pretty unbalanced

 

Elves
Dwarves
Gnomes
Orcs
Goblins
Ogres
Trolls
Griffins
Phoenixes
Dragons
Giants
Wyrms
Hobbits
Pig-men
Golems
etc

None of these are playable, but it is DIFFICULT to name a Generic High Fantasy species that *isnt* in wynncraft in one way or another!

 

based

________________________________

The issue isn't that stuff like dwarves and elves don't exist in the lore, because they do, and they're in game, it's that the story doesn't work if you are anything but human. The entirety of Fruma wouldn't be available to you if you weren't human

 

exactly

also i call it species because they just arent really races

Choosing your race would in this context imply being, for instance, an Almuj Human, a Bremminglar Human, a Nesaak Human, or a Ragni human (4 different "races")

Choosing a *species* is much less problematic ethics-wise, though awful lore wise

 

BASED !!

 

me playing wynncraft and holding a weapon as a phoenix

 

aww so sweet <3

 

I may have worded it poorly, the specific thread suggestion was to add Skyrim-style races - ie they're playable, not just NPCs. On the other hand, that's pretty evident from the discussion thus far.