Random Major Ids I Thought Of

Cataclysm: Rift
Smoke bombs last indefinitely but slowly lose damage over time, capping at 1 damage per tick
Monster: Shapeshift
Meteor and Ice Snake now have random ranges and sizes
Wybel Items: Typo
The stats of your weakest and strongest ids are switched
Alka Cometflinger: Comet
Your bomb spell now has a larger radius but no longer bounces
Zephra Shredder: Tornado
War Scream pulls foes towards it
Nepta Floodbringer: Wave
Ice Snake is now wave spell, but no longer slows foes down
Thrunda Ripsaw: Chaos
Spin Attack now spins three times, and Multihit has a larger radius
Inferna Flamewreath: Flashfire
Totem burns the floor when it lands, leaving a lasting effect after it disappears. Floor can be burned again with Uproot

 

reminds me of a certain funny skeleton man

 

My thoughts:
Rift: Indefinitely is kind of long, perhaps twice as long but after normal duration start decaying?
Shapeshift: Super cool, would it affect the damage? I was thinking about a damage size range of 90% of normal damage to 120% of normal damage, which is a bit rng based but not bad
Typo: what
Comet: seems odd, quite niche
Tornado: Interesting for kiting, strobelight already sort of accomplishes this by aggroing mobs to you whenever you use warscream
Wave: pretty cool but seems laggy
Chaos: Spin x3???? There better be reduced damage or a chance to occur to compensate for that otherwise thrunda is better than a mythic
Flashfire: Totem but meteor, like it a lot

 

1. sure
2. no
3. how
7. yeah, one spin attack does 1/3 damage

 

What does this exactly mean? Can I like casually get a +10 mana regen -12 mana steal Recharge? Or does it only affect the Wybel items, since that means I could still get a +2600 attack speed tier Stinger.

edit: no wait I could not get +2600 attack speed, but a +2600 HPR one is possible

 

for example, your weakest id is poison at -100/4s, and your strongest id is defence being +10. They switch, so now you have 10/4 poison and -100 defence.

 

yeah that's what I imagined. It's extremely overpowered, as can be seen in the examples I provided. The Uth IDs are fine, and I personally don't like Rift and Shapeshift that much, but they're ok too I guess.

 

Then what would the purpose of shapeshift be? Also typo seems way too powerful or will fuck over your build

 

1. Shapeshift would be to take out larger crowds of mobs/snipe mobs from far away. But I guess it should, the bigger the size the more damage it does
2. Yeah I agree, I think a better would just be to randomly buff one id and nerf another, and the buff and nerf changes everytime you switch out of the weap0n.

 

Rift: Why? I mean I guess its a neat idea but I feel like Cata is the last mythic that needs any sorta buff. If nothing else I'd put this on Grim.

Shapeshift: I fail to see the point here. This wouldn't give you any reason to change your current playstyle.

Typo: Based on the descriptions you gave in the comments this would be absurdly overpowered.

Comet: I really like this one however Alka as a weapon isn't particularly amazing and I am inclined to doubt that a major id such as this would fix it.

Tornado: Uhhh I actually really love this idea but the weapon its on feels wrong. Maybe Harwol instead?

Wave: Are you talking a wave like what most water bosses have? Cause if so that would be so freaking cool and super awesome. Also prob would wanna put it on lameme. However Nepta as is is extremely powerful and one of the best wands in the game and given I would imagine this to be a buff other changes to the item would likely be necessary (maybe +1 4th idk)

Chaos: What the fuck no please no no no no no no this is so insanely overpowered.

Flashfire: This is freaking awesome and would totally make Inferna worth using I love this idea. I'd love to give the id to other fire legendaries like crimson and cc as well.

 

not even gonna lie didnt read the range bit
why is typo even useful tho it just seems like some pointless rng