World [12+ Supporters] Crafting/gathering Suggestions Part 2: Special Material Nodes

I just don't see myself enjoying these node gimmicks much. they don't improve much on the general "gathering, crafting and utilizing" loop professions have right now and just add in some extra chance for excitement - which is definitely a good thing to add - I just don't really like the ideas. I support rare nodes though, since rather than having node gimmicks, it's something more direct and makes the grind for higher tier materials cooler.

 

What about the large nodes?

 

if you mean the large trees, I feel like they're just a bit overcomplex. rare nodes solve this by being a defined mechanic while large trees are mechanically very similar but exclusive to trees and only the big ones.

 

Of course.
After the fishing one was implemented, I slightly changed my opinion (I voted before it was there).
Overall, the large mining veins is the only suggestion I don't like that much, others are creative and nice.
The veins seem a little overcomplex; quickly spawning a node near the one you just dug not only would probably be not that easy to implement, the guaranteed tier 3 drop at the end should be severely nerfed, so it doesn't ruin the gathering economy with so much tier 3's being so easily dug.
Overall, a pretty nice and creative suggestion.
+.5

 

The percentages for rare nodes + veins are below the percentages you actually get T2s and T3s so that doesn't make any sense. Node monsters would be annoying and stupid, mining is meant to be peaceful. Weeds wouldn't be a good idea as it would just lessen the amount of materials people would get and despite giving you xp slow the game down. I do like the school of fish idea and I'm indifferent to the large tree one though

 

Weeds would only have a chance of being gathered if you wouldn't recieve a crop. The refining chance would stay the same, but, if the crop failed to refine, there would be a chance to recieve a weed

 

Removed weeds, added new farming suggestion

 

How is +0.5 a full supporter? There's a difference between +1 and +0.5 (refering to the title)

Also, good idea to remove weeds. I didn't really like the idea lol, hard to implement and no point


EDIT: Oh no, soil

 

Just a supporter of the general idea would be .5
Anything positive is a “supporter”, but the overall support is “7.5”

 

Yeah it would be if you took into account people who don't like it, or don't like it that much