Floating Island Lore Idea

So how exactly did it influence your life

 

or maybe one of the developers shat out a couple of blocks

 

That's beyond the point. The point is that there's no need for useless backstory on tiny little things. There's nothing wrong with them just being. Why add useless redundant backstory?

As for your tryhard questions; 1. Yes, because this is not reality. Also, why is this important in the slightest? 2. No. Again, importance is what?

 

The Talking Mushroom could have just be a mushroom used in a quest. But no. :)

________________________________

Just read the idea of this player :)

 

That's exactly what it is. Once more, beyond the point.

Will you ever actually cover all of my points, or will you continue to only take small parts of them?

 

I will continue to take small parts of them because it's fun. :D

 

The grass block at 458 -1498 could have just been there to be part of the world. But apparently it has a backstory according to you

 

And if you want to know :

I'm saying all these things because I want to be nice with someone who try to give out ideas about things even if it is a little thing.
What do you do ? You are throwing your rudeness at him with a stupid meme...

________________________________

Why not ? Some peoples did a backstory on the village that was on the map some years ago.

 

Criticism is not rudeness. If you think it is, kindly exit the safespace.

 

Its a gif tho....

Village ≠ grass block

 

But if we follow what you say. It's irrevelant because it's little and we can't even go to it.

If you are new to a place, and you try to say something to have the interest of the others, would you like that someone say that what you are doing is useless ?

 

That supports @captainganon 's point though..... that island is irrelevant and its little

 

If I made something useless, I'd prefer people tell me it's useless. That way, I can fix and improve it. The best way to get better is to make mistakes.

 

The thing he did is not even useless... He try to give out ideas...

And if you like posting meme and GIF :
:D

 

You said useless. Don't pin the blame on me. I only repeated the word because I was answering your question.

As I said, the only way to improve your ideas is to receive criticism on them. My criticism; you don't need a backstory for every little block, and especially not such a complicated one. To improve, he could've a) completely redone the idea or b) Lessened the depth of the backstory so that it's not overly elaborate.

 

If he likes to do this, why do you blame him for doing to many details ?

________________________________

Before doing thing that will make people happy, you need to do things that will make YOURSELF happy.

 

Right let's not start talking philosophy shall we?

This was a suggestion, albeit one in the wrong section. It is open to critique; he even admitted that some people may be "here to tell me that my idea is already a thing and that I am stupid." While that's not what I'm trying to do, he should be perfectly fine with being challenged on the subject.

This is not a case of me disliking him doing what he likes doing; this is a suggestion. What's important isn't what he enjoys, it's the quality of the suggestion. This server isn't his; his happiness doesn't override the quality of the server.

 

holy shit we really managed to start an argument over a 5x5 square

 

Well you all can keep saying it's an irrelevant, useless, small island
But the fact that it's unique... it is the only 'floating' island across those lands, the fact that it has a small waterfall that is going into the ocean, and it's actually the source of that water, doesn't make it 'useless, irrelevant island' at damn all.
It isn't there just to be there, knowing Wynn, NOTHING is there without a reason. Especially as unique as that island is. I don't believe it's just a tricky hidden chest spot. It looks like it should mean something anyway

EDT: if it really does not mean anything and is just a part of landscape with no story and hidden context, I'm sad :( cause actually have potential to mean more than just being a couple of blocks

 

And to add something to this :
If it was so irrevelant, it would have been remove with the revamp of Wynn.