Would A Quest For Half Moon Island Ruin It?

So yesterday I made a quest suggestion for Skien's Island, but it appears the community doesn't want that, so before I go on making a quest for Half Moon Island I just want to know if it would be a good idea.

 

There's nothing wrong with making a quest suggestion: it's just a suggestion, if it's unwanted, it probably won't be added. That said, I do think a quest for Half Moon Island would ruin it. Quests (especially in Wynncraft) follow a very linear structure, allowing little to no exploration or interpretation. The mystery would be ruined. I suppose the challenge would be to design a quest that keeps the mystery intact, something akin to ???, The House of Twain or Fantastic Voyage.

 

What's great about the smaller and more irrelevant islands is that they are made for explorers to mess around on and not for quests. It also adds a little immersion with the fact that not every place has a quest for you