Realm of Light III - A Headless History Bugged

Hi, so I got to stage 9 of the quest, but my new wireless mouse's receiver for some reason fritzed and caused me to die since I couldn't turn around or cast any spells. I respawned in one of the towns like normal, but when I got back to the castle and tried to get past the first room I found I couldn't. For some reason, I am unable to get the first key needed to move on again. I have the 2nd key, since I had defeated the Spirit of the Keeper of Keys before my mouse fritzed and caused me to die, but no longer the first. I checked the Wynncraft Wiki to see if I was just doing something wrong, but I'm not. If someone could please help me, that would be great!!

 

I would try /class and swapping worlds if you haven't already and make sure both statues have lowered their swords. Otherwise the only other failsafe I can think of would be to find someone who's also doing the quest and have them activate the statues to get access to the first key