Warrior/Knight Help Defense Or Damage

So i was making/stealing Warrior buikdans, but i couldnt decide if i went with Guardian or Alkatraz.
Here are the builds i have
Guardian:
https://wynndata.tk/s/Eezy5O
Alkatraz:
https://wynndata.tk/s/Qb6VPp

So Witch one is better/more viable or is threre an even better build?

 

damage

 

Idk if you noticed or not but the guardian build doesn't even work because of double master hive. Also I noticed the damage and defense bonuses have been messed with on the alkatraz build. While setting them lower is fine, the earth damage % is set higher than it can possibly get, as wynndata takes the max value, so reset that back to what it was before. The cap for skill points is 150 (80.8%), so adding extra sp to strength after 150 is worthless (which is what is in the build). As for improving the alkatraz build, this is better in the elemental defense and dps department https://wynndata.tk/s/C3HQ79.

As for guardian, going tank guardian (unless you want to help people and be a literal unkillable meatshield rather than do any real amounts of damage to actual high level bosses) is pretty useless imo. You can utilize guardian in an actual damage build due to its hp allowing you to use glassier fire items, such as here https://wynndata.tk/s/xCYcVg or https://wynndata.tk/s/BLxy3h. While probably not the best examples, this shows that you can still get good damage with guardian and still be pretty tanky. It comes down to preference of which you want to use though.

 

Tnx Guys i really appericiate it.