Okay, this is actually amazing! I joined PUN recently (but didn't get to help with this, even though I would really have liked to) and really looking at it the only thing worth staying for was the community, which is to say that the gameplay aspect of the guild was entirely boring. In fact, the only gameplay part I greatly enjoy was the event making, a part of the guild that was totally separate from Wynn. Some of the suggestions here I was unsure of at first, wondering what they would really add (the main one being guild halls which after reading what the function of them would be is now one of the things I want added most), but all but one of the ideas (that idea being about consumables that I heard the person making this post would change as they forgot a part of it) are extremely good ones and would probably not fully fix guilds, but would make them more then just community and instead actually make them fun ingame! Overall, these ideas are amazing and this person should be given a medal! Good fricking job with all of this!!