Is The Order Of The Grook Reward Based On Your Items? Or Is It Random?

i started the order of the grook quest and needed some help , so i pulled up a guide and saw that your reward was based on your wand , i got the oak wood wand so i started to freak out , realizing there was nothing i could do i just did the quest , but at the end i got the ring , so did they change it to be random or did the change the wands rewards ?

 

it still depends on the wands. the rewards got changed so that every wand gives you an accessory, so you don't just miss out on them just because you chose wrong

 

yeah i was mad when i saw the outdated spread sheet , i wanted the dragons eye bleach , but i chose wrong and got the ring