SPOILER Which Do You Think Is Harder?

In my perspective: Tasim the Protector > The Eye > Aledar the Exterminator

 

imo both are easy, but the eye slightly edges out aledar+tasim since wretches usually mean certain death with low dps/spell shaman(aura trap BLJ wretches are a thing D:), while aledar/tasim phase 3 is just a dps test

 

Aledar and Tasim are harder because you can't fight them without the eye which means:
Aledar&Tasim = Aledar&Tasim + Eye
Eye = Eye

 

well, I can beat aledar and tasim with ETW, I have yet to succeed against the EYE in that department

 

i can solo eye
but i lost to tasim 6x in a row while 2v1 with a friend, using sp pots

is it actually just me who thinks tasim is stronger by a long shot

 

The Eye is harder if you do it the first time (because you dont know the special attack or how to react to the Eyes "standart" attacks) but after you defeated the Eye a few times it becomes a lot easier. So Aledar&Tasim are harder because of that...

 

Tasim resists fire.

 

If you subtract Aledar&Tasim from both sides of the equation then you get Eye=0

 

basically, The Eye is a LOT harder mechanically, even if Aledar and Tasim are physically stronger.
For A and T, you need a little bit of normal combat skill and a good build.

For the eye on the other hand, you need not only an ok build, but also knowledge of its unique attacks

 

If you have good reactions then not. Wretch? HP pot as soon as you get the health off and you are semi-safe with new experince. And that was the only one you really should know

 

idk, i died to the explosion rings twice before noticing that they were what was killing me



yes i know i was glassy

 

It took me two tries to beat the Eye, and like 15 tries and a carry with Aledar and Tasim
In fairness, I think I overprepared for the Eye and underprepared for Aledar and Tasim
I also couldn't afford stat pots when I fought Aledar and Tasim because I had spent all of my money on tp scrolls for the rest of ahc

 

Aledar and Tasim are harder because The Eye follows distinct patterns, making it a fight you can easily memorize.

 

Ok, good point.
Fixed equation:
Aledar&Tasimtotal = Aledar&Tasim1 + TheEye1
TheEyetotal = TheEye1

If you couldn't tell, the small letters are supposed to be subscript.

 

Aledar and Tasim each have two eyes making them four times harder than the eye.

All jokes aside, I still think Aledar and Tasim are harder. The fight is more chaotic, leaving you with less time to think and use pots. The Eye took me three attempts, while Aledar and Tasim took me five. However, in the Eye I used skill pots. You may wonder how that makes Aledar and Tasim harder, if I beat them without skill pots. Well you see, it's not that I didn't use skill pots, it's that I couldn't. As said earlier, Aledar and Tasim are way more chaotic than the Eye. Because of my lack of skill pots, I dropped below 25% of my total health in the third phase multiple times. In my first successful attempt at the Eye, I only dropped this low because of a wretch. To add on to this, dropping to low health on the Eye isn't much of a big deal, as you can spam heal pots. Aledar, especially in his third phase won't let you do that. To top it all off, if you accidentally kill Aledar in the first phase, you're pretty much dead.

 

For me the eye was crazy, can't cheese too hard by running hard counters with powders either.

 

I have fought neither

 

where is the aledar cart option

 

I waited until after I did the quest before posting here, and the eye is definitely harder. I could hit phase 3 and then get shredded by lag or combos until I ran into someone else fighting him too, still with too many close calls. Aledar was not hard after realizing what I should be doing in the first part with the duo, same build and no defense Potions.