Warrior/Knight Help Which Build Would Be Better? (thunder-spellwarrior)

Changed on 22/7/2018 since I realise that I need advice again...Sigh.
Edit again : Help found, thread can probably be closed since the build works fine for me. Just going to leave what is here for others' reference but more suggestions would be welcomed as well.
So here we have two Thunder Spell builds, one having more damage + health but the other having higher elemental Defense (Since it does not make much difference on Mana it can be neglected as a comparing factor) :

I-got-less-health-less-damage-but-more-defense-build:
https://wynndata.tk/s/hl76jn

I-got-more-health-more-damage-but-less-defense-build:
https://wynndata.tk/s/WLhGdJ
(Not totally original with this one, had looked for reference elsewhere.)

So here is the problem : If with less elemental Defense, the health advantage might be nothing when ultimately compared. Which one of those two builds would fare better overall, and would there be even better options?

Thank you very much for reading this thread and the help offered.


------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Original : Seeking A Thunder Melee Build

Not really a viable idea, but I still want to give this a go.
Would appreciate some help on creating this build---Though it is unlikely to be usable.
Aiming to have Super Fast Attack speed and maybe a bit less of a glass-cannon, dead element defense is fine. (Earth is exception.)
Inb4 someone asks why not earth, it is because thunder seems more fun.

 

Warrior -> Warrior Help Prefix

 

Fixed, thank you for pointing it out.

 

maybe something like this using hive spear?
also this one has a bit more hp but less dps?
storm brewer could work as an alternative for slayer

 

Idk if you noticed this or not but you put +4 tier attack speed when you only need +3 to make hive spear superfast
anyways this is my attempt at it https://wynndata.tk/s/UdoYQX

 

didn't even notice, thought it was slow attack speed. thanks for notifying me :P

________________________________

maybe this could also work. the little bit of life steal should counter the negative health regen

 

This actually looks doable...Though I do not have slayer, I can try Storm Brewer instead as suggested. (Or maybe Shaggy Boots? I'll have to test that out...)
Thank you very much for sharing these builds!

Whoa...another neat build! I guess I did not specify at first, but I do have a thrunda that I can use so I think I'll try to adjust it with less Tier bonus and more damage...But I never thought Hive spear can do this much damage! Allow me to express my gratitude for your help.

 

I'd prefer the second one over the first one

I'd prefer this https://wynndata.tk/s/tyVbAG over either but it comes down to personal preference

 

So less defense would be fine, I see.
And thank you very much for helping me out again, I'd hate to trouble people but I am but a small potato on making builds. Allow me to express my gratitude. This build's capability for spamming while with good damage...Just wow.