Guide Mythic Bows Compared To Substitutes

So, ive compared all the mythic bows to the most similar bow to it
and presented it in the form of items (i guess?)

The data is made from the highest for positive stats and lowest for negative stats.
Eg. a bow has -20% Melee Damage to -30% Melee Damage, the 30% will be used

stats are taken from wynndata

I Havent calculated together the attack tiers yet
so the damages might not be comparably right
(except for ones that are the same attack tier)

The data favours the mythic, saying whether using it is better or worse in each stats.

I hope this shows some insight to whether some of the mythic bows are worth it, or a substitute is almost equal and just as viable :)
Key:
■:Using The Mythic Will Make this Stat Worse
■: Using The Mythic will negate this stat (make it 0) (can kindof be ignored honestly)
■: Using The Mythic Will make this stat better

Spoiler: Ignis

Compared to Hellstrand

+1 Attack Tier
-130/280 Neutral damage
+50/-20 Fire Damage
+3 Level req
+80 Def req

-72% health regen
-390/4s Life Steal
-2/4 Mana Steal
-13 Dexterity
+17% soul point regen
-20% spell damage
+28% water damage
-26% Thunder damage
-26% Air defence
+455 Health Regen
+13 Defence
+13% Thorns
+3900 Health
+13% Reflection
+7% Melee Damage
+11% Fire Damage
+26% Fire Defence
+13% Thunder Defence
+13% Earth Defence

Spoiler: Grandmother

Compared to Doubt

+2 Attack Tier
-395/510 Neutral Damage
-90/260 Earth Damage
+2 Level Req

-13% Melee Damage
+7% Spell Damage
-12% Earth Defence
-20% Earth Damage
-10% Walk Speed
+38% Thunder Damage
+24% Air Damage
+24% Water Damagee
+10% Fire Damage
+13% XP Bonus
+26% Loot Bonus
-17% Health Regen
-259 Health Regen

+3 Powder Slots

Spoiler: Strati

Compared to Gales Force

-1 Attack Tier
-10/50 Neutral Damage
+80/205 Air Damage
+4 Level Req
-20 Dex Req
+50 Agi Req

-20% Xp Bonus
-7 Dexterity
+7 Agility
+52% Walk Speed
-10% Soul Point Regen
-13% Reflection
-26% Air Damage
+35% Earth Damage
-26% Air Defence
-13% Thunder Defence
-1050 Health
+13% Spell Damage
+13% Melee Damage

Spoiler: Freedom

Compared to Awakening

+40/0 Fire Damage
+20/-15 Water Damage
+30/0 Air Damage
-30/+70 Thunder Damage
+60/35 Earth Damage

+2/4 Mana Regen
-8 Strength
-8 Dexterity
-8 Intelligence
-8 Agility
-8 Defence
+8% Walk Speed
+780 Health
+169 Spell Damage
+104 Melee Damage
+3% Earth Damage
+3% Thunder Damage
+3% Water Damage
+3% Air Damage
+3% Fire Damage

+4 Powder Slots

Spoiler: Az

Compared to Corrupted Witherheads Bow
+5/15 Neutral Damage
+9/70 Thunder Damage
+5 Dex Req
-10 Agi Req

-4 Dexterity
+11% XP Bonus
+11% Fire Damage
+11% Water Damage
+4% Thunder Damage
-14% Air Damage
-20% Spell Damage
+10% Soul Point Regen
+20% Walk Speed

Spoiler: Spring

Compared to Torrential Tide

-3 Attack Tier
+299/310 Neutral Damage
+100/-10
+15 Str Req
+60 Int Req

-4/4 Mana Steal
+4/4 Mana Regen
+2 Intelligence
+14% Water Damage
-520 Spell Damage
+195 Health Regen
+11% Thunder Damage
-3 Dexterity
+28% Exploding
+350 Health
+31% Melee Damage
+70% Fire Damage

+2 Powder Slots

 

Basically comparing mythics to poor mans mythics

 

add meta builds or commonly used builds for each mythic / mythic sub

 

no.

 

why 10 char

 

This is only about comparing the bows, not the builds people use in them

 

By adding builds you can get how much damage differ, no one actually used just the bow..

 

hey that's pretty cool

 

the presentation of this comparison so misleading i dont even know how to begin

but given that all these stats are probably gonna change when the rebalance comes (in 30 years) theres no point in doing so anyways ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

 

Tell me how to improve it then

And I'm gonna change the stats once they get changed

 

There are other replacement items that imo are better than the ones used. Also, using red, orange, and green doesn't fairly compare the stats. I suggest showing the stats of both items side by side and comparing them, rather than putting the stats together in one 'item stat list'. If you show both, or multiple in the case of other good replacements, of the bows' stats, that would help give readers more context. Having the legend to describe the coloring is all a wynncrafter can use when viewing this. It removes the readers past experience in game, and almost requires people to think completely different. Just side by side comparisons would be better. Follow that up with intelligent discussion about why chosing this replacement over the mythic or other replacement is the best choice for xyz and y the mythic or other replacements are not to be scoffed at either, but maybe used in different situations.

 

Just show the stats side-by-side; make a table or something

 

The choice of topic for this thread was good (comparing Mythics to lower rarity replacement items), but the execution was sub-par so I voted nee. Might change if the thread is improved.

 

Uhm, Hellstrand is shit, try adding a replacement using Plague. Also Fog of Creation > Awakening.

 

My thoughts exactly

 

do mythic spear compared to its substitutes plz