Fix Pvp Brainstorm Discussion

how could we fix pvp so both parties are satisfied?

i'm thinking of a stamina bar so you can dish out as many attacks as you like but you have to wait 15 seconds if you run out of stamina

 

Remove pvp, problem solved

 

good thinking if there is no pvp there are no pvp fans /s

but i really want to talk about it, i thought this was going to explode with replies

 

./gamerule ItemCooldown false|true

 

we already can change the attack speed of weapons we don't need that, you can make custom items by commands by using attribute modifiers

 

yeh but people are too lazy for it

 

Man attempts to turn minecraft into dungeon realms Circa 2018.

 

Honestly, I've decided to play around with the newer combat system since I'm moving from 1.7 to 1.12 in terms of modding, and I've started to really like it in terms of PvE. In terms of PvP I'm 50/50 because I hate all Minecraft PvP in general.

Your proposal with the stamina bar does sound interesting, but it seems more limiting than the current system in terms of creativity (remember: I'm being biased towards PvE/mods here). The thing I like about the current system is that you can have something akin to Wynn's system with weapons that do high damage but have a low cooldown. You could make it so these weapons use more stamina in your system but still...

Also, even if they change it again people will just continue whining forever until they change it to the old system.

I've never been a fan of easily being able to turn it off, because for vanilla, it'll make the game easy now that we have stuff like shields which are powerful. Now combine shields with being able to spam click for more damage... Yeah.

What if someone makes a weapon that's really powerful but has a slow cooldown? Being able to turn that cooldown off screws up the balance.

As for how to make both parties satisfied... I honestly don't know. People who like the new system are pretty fine with it, and people who like the old one seem like they'll never be satisfied until they just get the old one back, but if they get the old one back they'll have to rebalance everything again... Then you'll make the proponents of the newer system mad... Yeah.

Hell, just make it so that hitting players recharges it instantly, don't know how you could make that non-abuseable with PvE though... Do you see the problem yet? I wish the PvP community wasn't so annoying.

 

i like the idea of if you hit someone it recharges instantly

 

There could be a system in that the longer you wait in between attacks the more damage you deal. Spamming your attacks would still work and so would waiting in between attacks.