Mafia Game

Night has ended.

GenericJoe420 has died. He was a Town Tracker.

It is now day. You may post. The deadline for Day 2 is 9:07 PM EST on 6/22/17.


If you are playing in the game and have liked a post in it, please remove your like before I give you a warning.

 

See this is what happens when we nolynch.
Town gets a free kill.
I somehow thought that GenericJoe was scum because it looked like he was trying to feign doctor, but whatever.
Strataformis(whoops did i spell dat rite)

I like you NPCGrian, but you really need to read. If the cop/tracker dies, then who will we know how to lynch? Then we lose because nobody lynches?
EVERYBODY READ THIS: ITS MANDATORY: http://aops-mafia.wikia.com/wiki/AoPS_Mafia_Newbie_Guide

You can; everyone discusses, gives their reads, and ends up with a result. You just wasted Day 1 people, nice job. Let me guess: you'll only lynch if someone claims cop and attacks someone?
And then the cop/tracker dies.
Yay.
There's a lot of games where scumhunting won the game. Just read.

This quote makes me either think a) this person is doctor b) this person is mafia.
First of all, when someone asks for clarifications about role $x$, he is more likely to be $x$ than any other non-VT role.
Secondly, he just jumped on the no-lynch wagon without discussion.

No. No-lynching is stupid unless it's MyLo. How come nobody responded to my evidence?

This: bandwagoning at its best.
At least we could've discussed and found more evidence towards someone being scummier or not.

No lynching is a bad idea. We just lynch someone random if nobody is scummy; if not, an inactive who hasn't posted.

Reads:(10 is town 1 is scum)

1. @Pokextreme - 5, nothing much
2. @Oryx - 3, Blatant bandwagon at night, shows he just wants to follow the majority. Looks like he wanted mafia to get more kills.
3. @Josh_Legacy - 4, his "simple, you don't" wasn't at all helpful.
4. @GeneralCobra19 - 10. This person contributed the most, and is checking all the other players' sanity at the same time. \sarcasm
5. @NPCGrian - 4 Same reads, and actually argued his point. However, he was on the wagon, so I'm not sure. His liking of the post shows that he is too lazy to read the rules(even at a game he hasn't even played before) so he is a little scummier.
6. @ImpulseCake - 4 Bandwagon, see @Oryx. Except he wasn't THAT anxious to post during night.
7. @Gigavern - 5, contributed nothing.
8. @genericjoe43 - 3, bandwagons and fake contribution. And you seem TOO anxious to get a kill or Nolynch in. Also fake doctor hint... looks scummy.
9. @Original_Potato - 5, same as @Pokextreme

Also, @summitwei NPCGrian should receive a warning for liking genericjoe's post, which also makes me suspect them as a possible scumteam pairing.

Genericjoe looks like he's trying to feign doctor: he could've PM'ed it to summitwei if he WAS doctor.

ALSO NOBODY VOTE UNTIL THE LATE SECOND IRL DAY

I'd encourage(no yell at) everyone to COMPLETELY read this: http://aops-mafia.wikia.com/wiki/AoPS_Mafia_Newbie_Guide. And an AoPS or MU mafia game, at least 200 mid-game posts. GO.

NOW.

________________________________

It's pretty natural for BP to claim early(AoPS mafia did this), so:
/claim 1-Shot BP
ok there
whoops i made my post during night before genericjoe died so i thought he was scum.

 

._.
I DID READ THE RULES AS A MATTER OF FACT
IF YOULL LOOK AT MY PROFILE I LIKE MOST POSTS I SEE. I ONLY REMEMBER AFTER AND UNLIKED
And no I wasn't on the bandwagon. I had decided against lynching as soon as I was aware of the circumstances, in comparison to IRL games I've played.

 

You were on the wagon of no-lynch. I'll let that slide, but after the death, I'm reading you as 5.5/10.

________________________________

Or how about this?
Here's evidence its stilll liked.

 

My decision was not based on those of others.

 

Ok fine then, but I'd have to say that you still liked itt.
GRITRTTRRCTRTRATRTRTRTERTRTR (mutters something that happened not in this game)

 

As I said, I liked it of habit, realized my mistake, and unliked. I never denied liking

 

No you did not.

 

._.
And why would you be one to make such a claim? I told you what happened. Since you obviously want don't care what I say, I will stop arguing

 

generalcobra its day 1 ffs. I myself find scumreading day 1 hard, but it usually builds up. Day1 is useless in my opinion cause many people have different prsonalities.

 

Its Stratiformis =P.
Tbh, bandwagon is the real killer

 

oh and
your not the boss of me.
I decide when i waant to vote
and right now, your putting me on edge, however isee your experienced
so i think its just an act

________________________________

im leaning toward you being mafia.

________________________________

rright now your trying to ascertain your innocence, but who knows you may backstab us in the end

 

So to clarify, Bandwagoning is seen as scummy because:

• The wagon was heading in the direction of No-Lynch which was bad as we were not in MyLo.
• It can act as a disguise for the Mafia quite easily because almost everyone trusts that decision as well.
• It is a logical fallacy.

?

 

while bandwagoning is a logical fallacy, it seems to be apparnt very quickly

________________________________

oh

im just stating the kinda obvious
but
everyone should be sus of eachother, hell i might be mafia

 

Then so is scumhunting in general? Again, day 2 is useless as well, and since our tracker is down, we actually have to scumhunt.
I'm confirmed town since nobody counterclaimed me; whoever does is immediately ousted as scum following my lynch.

Bandwagoning is also a way not to be attacked, and scum don't want to be attacked the most.

You are dead. You cannot post. You are the tracker.
And "just an act"?
I've played seven forum mafia games, and in two other right now.
How is this just an act?
And all the posts are quality of my level.
(or higher)

Unless someone claims BP or doctor, I'm confirmed BP since town doesn't lie. If someone counterclaims, one of us is scum, and the other town. Hence my lynch would get him killed.

 

Genericjoe420 (Oryx) was killed not #43.

 

How am I mafia?
I'm putting you on edge because I thought you were scum. Accusing somebody for being scum is not scummy.
?
He was killed

 

The person who you were talking to was 43 not 420 (the person in the spoiler)

 

Oh ok
I'm confirmed town
How is everyone scumreading me?
You should be townreading me for contribution, or null at best.

Attacking people for scumreading them is not helpful, and attacking someone based on contribution is even worse. For those who haven't, read the newbie guide. Now.

________________________________

So are you. What if you are trying to ascertain your innocence, but you may be scum and backstab us in the end?
And obviously, I'm town no matter what you say.
And if everyone decides when they want to vote we're gonna end up with the same thing in D1. This is why I'm telling you: I can't trust you to lynch correctly.
I'm advising you. If you want to be idiots and pull a [mafia game 73], go right ahead! It's majority opinion after all. I'm just trying to prevent that.

 

Ok fine, your town. But doesn't that just put a bigger target/bullseye on you. The only experience I have with Mafia is in Town of Salem. In that game, the most helpful people are usually the first to die. It would only make sense for the scum to get rid of the smart people first. That's why no one is just shouting out thier role. And why everyone is super suspicious of each other. Like @genericjoe43 said, I could be mafia too.