64 Liquefied Emerald Giveaway!

in which aspect am i not reading?

 

I think antra means the requirement in your YouTube description where you have to comment on the video in order to enter? Am I right @Antra

 

my question to that is then in all due respect 'what gives them the right to control what i write in the description of my youtube video?"

 

Well, you removed the subscribe and like portions. Commenting is a REQUIREMENT because you have to SEE the usernames. Not everyone knows how to run google polls and enter pages.
I feel that if you really want to get SO upset over having to spend 5 seconds on a video to leave your ign, don't bother. It isn't a requirement to join the giveaway. Get over it.

Note: I don't agree with leaving a like or subscribe for the giveaway. That @KingRobbo changed and it should be fine.

 

my qustion is then if i set up a giveaway site, like gleam.io . would that be considered as being okay.

 

My question is what's wrong with people writing in their IGN's here on the thread to enter?

 

nothing is wrong with that, can you answer mine now?

 

1: reply button
2: Commenting on the thread, pretzule just said that

 

so just to clear it up, the problem that people have is that the youtube vid asks them to comment their ign in the comments...

 

OOOOoooo Me likey!
CassFaith

 

the logic of this thread is out of control

 

IGN: Redcowboycraft

just saying this is more a flame war then a giveaway kinda-ish

 

well it was intended as a giveaway thread, but people werent too happy with that...

 

They just don't want you promoting your channel with giveaways

 

Why a video???
Why not just make people place a comment on this thread, Which is the, btw the frickin' forums for the game you are doing a giveaway on.
This isn't the way to popularity on YT

 

i understand that, and if i was doing it for popularity on youtube, i wouldnt have made it a unlisted video. I simply used it as medium to collect entries, as you ahve seen here, the forums comments can be a pain in the arse to search through finding entries.

 

its the same way as youtube, but doing as you did, is illegal (according to @Pretzule)

 

so what your saying, because my yt vid asks people to leave their ign in the comments, i cant do that, because its wynncraft related?

 

You can ask people to comment or whatever all you want on your own video on youtube. However, if you connect it to wynn and make them do so for Le,then it causes problems.

I know you said you aren't doing this for promoting your video, but anyone can use that excuse and abuse the heck out of this.

 

NO,

asking for likes/comments/subs for a wynncraft giveaway (lets not talk about the art and the music you used for the video without giving credits), is illegal!

how hard is that ?!