Any Class Help Adamantite Or Andesite Aegis?

The title says it all. Which should I choose and why? I will post snapshots of both as soon as I can get them.

If you are a helpful person, help me with my other issues: https://forums.wynncraft.com/threads/return-to-ether-or-gales-force.165610/ and https://forums.wynncraft.com/threads/is-gravity-worth-it.165612/

 

Adamantite sucks never use it andesite is 100x better

 

Why?

 

Adamantite reduces all elemental defenses and damages, its only pro is pure health. It's really takes away from your build instead of adding to it.
Andesite is better for the tank that you want. A little less health, but it has regen, defense (a lot more defense), etc

 

yes, but adamantite gives so much health. Mine gives 4400+ health

 

What are you trying to say?

 

with adamantite you may get more health but due to the fact that you just take a sheet ton more dmg that extra health doesnt mean anything really .-. (at least not for tanking)

 

okay thx.