Underice Decision

I just want to know what the different rewards are because I can find the name of the items but no other information. My inclination is to give the fish to the squids but I obviously want the best reward for my character.
Thanks

 

I think the only difference is the necklace you get.

 

A weapon for level 40 if you give the puffer fish to Calamaro and a necklace for level 40 if you give it to the villager which gives elemental defenses

 

what class?

 

I've seen the weapons and in my opinion they aren't the best.. you should go for the necklace.

 

A weapon for whatever class you want

 

ah I get it
It's Calamaros token, so I guess there's a merchant there?

 

Yeah but unless your level 40 and need a better weapon go for the necklace

 

that's what I did :P

 

Same but I got rid of it for a Jester Necklace

 

It's still pretty good for its level tho

 

You get the the same reward no matter what. You giver to either the old man or the squid and then go back to the Start Quest NPC and he will give you're reward. Also, how did you get the lore? I'm having trouble with that part

 

No they're is one reward difference depending on your choice.

Calamaro's Token which can be traded for a water weapon at level 40
And Girard's Necklace which gives elemental defense to all element.

________________________________

True but I'm level 59 and without any quests to do I need XP bonus to grind

 

thanks for the help

 

If you choose to give the pufferfish to Calamaro, you get these choices:




And if you choose to give the pufferfish to Gernald, you get this:




These could change depending on the update and class as these items are with using the Mage class at level 43 and using the version of Wynncraft that is: Version 1.14.2 Patch #2.